Skip to main content

Hot Take: The Detroit Lions May Be Better Off Without Aidan Hutchinson

The Detroit Lions improved to an NFC North-leading 7-2 this past weekend, after dominating the defending-AFC Champion New England Patriots in Munich, Germany, 35-10. How did their power-ranking shift after their impressive showing across the pond?

Sports Illustrated
Last Week: 6th
This Week: 9th
Change: -3

The Athletic
Last Week: 8th
This Week: 9th
Change: -1

Bleacher Report
Last Week: 8th
This Week: 9th
Change: -1

Fox Sports
Last Week: 10th
This Week: 9th
Change: +1

Sporting News
Last Week: 10th
This Week: 8th
Change: +2

CBS Sportws
Last Week: 8th
This Week: 8th
Change: +/- 0

Total Change: -2

So, the now NFC North-leading Detroit Lions dominate the defending-AFC Champion New England Patriots, and they fall in the power-rankings? Why, how in the world? 

Because of one play, one single play early in the game. At the tail-end of the Patriots' opening possession, Lions d-end, Aidan Hutchinson, chased down Patriots quarterback Drake Maye, and awkwardly tackled him. Maye's ankle was injured on the play. After the sack, Hutchinson celebrated by jumping high into the air and landing awkwardly, tearing an ACL in the process. He's now being ruled out for the remainder of the season. Maye is expected to miss significant time as well. So, that's it. NFL analyst after analyst has said the Lions are finished, that they may limp into the playoffs, but won't have any postseason success, due to Hutchinson's injury. Well, if history is any guide, that's not at all accurate, and oddly enough, may be antithetical to what will ensue. 

Aidan Hutchinson is the name, the face of the Detroit Lions defense, but this isn't the first time the star defensive end has been injured. Early in the 2024 season, he broke the other leg and missed the final 12 games of the regular season. To this point, the Lions have played 65 games with Hutchinson starting and 12 games without him in the lineup. Here's a breakdown of those very numbers.

With Hutchinson (65 games)
Record: 41-24 (.631)
Points: 1,803-1,525 (27.7 - 23.5 = +4.2)

Without Hutchinson (12 games)
Record: 11-1 (.917)
Points: 413-251 (34.4 - 20.9 = +13.5)

Sure, it's a smaller sample size, but it's 71% of a full season. That's not nothing. This is even including Hutchinson's start in this past week's game, where he only played a few snaps. The Lions defense allowed 3 points with Hutchinson in the game, which was close to 6 minutes of gametime. Detroit's defense allowed only 7 points, without Hutchinson, in the remaining 54 minutes. Sure, you can argue, "Hey, but Drake Maye wasn't playing!" Fine, fine, but the argument surrounds the Detroit Lions defense and how ineffective they'll allegedly be following Aidan Hutchinson's season-ending injury. No matter who was at quarterback for the New England Patriots, post-first possession, the Lions defense kept him in check. They were, :: gasp ::, effective.

Aidan Hutchinson is a solid d-end, but he's not the best; he's not even elite. While he may be the face of the defense, he is not its leader. When I watch the Detroit Lions defense, I don't think, "This is Aidan Hutchinson's team;" I say, "This is Dan Campbell's team." The Lions have suffered more defensive injuries over the past few years than Albert Einstein could even count. They may go to a third-stringer in the secondary, an undrafted free agent on the line, and a player nobody's ever heard of in the middle, yet they always fight and find ways of improving as the season progresses. Just look at this season. 

After the first four weeks, and a 2-2 record to show for it, the Lions defense had given up a league-leading 127 points, or 31.8 per game. Over their past five games, and a 5-0 record to show for it, they've allowed only 72 points, or 14.4 per contest. There may be a regression to the mean to close the season, but that was bound to happen with or without Hutchinson. Even if they allow 20-25 points per game to close the season, here's what they're going up against.

vs. 3-6 Tampa Bay
vs. 7-2 Chicago
@ 3-7 Atlanta
vs. 1-8 Tennessee
@ 7-2 Minnesota
vs. 5-3-1 NY Giants
@ 7-2 Chicago
@ 6-4 Green Bay

Tampa Bay has certainly improved, especially defensively, but in the Motor City, I give the edge to the Lions, which would improve them to 8-2.

Technically, there's a 3-way tie for first place in the North, with Detroit, Chicago, and Minnesota all possessing identical 7-2 records. Detroit has the edge in tie-breakers, however, as they are currently a perfect 2-0 in division, including a win over the Vikings. So, the game against the Bears is a big one. Bears head coach and former Lions offensive coordinator, Ben Johnson, is currently 0-2 against his former team. At Ford Field a year ago, Johnson's current team got trounced by his former one, 52-21. I'm not expecting anything of the sort this go-round, but will give the home team the advantage, and take the Lions in a shootout, to vault them to 9-2.

The Atlanta Falcons are a tricky team to figure out. They've looked like garbage against teams like Carolina and Tampa, yet are the only team to defeat the 8-1 San Francisco 49ers thus far. While I wouldn't be shocked by a Falcons victory in this game, I do believe the Lions have the better team, so I'll stick with them, bringing their record to 10-2.

Don't laugh, but like Miami, Tennessee is better than their 1-8 record would indicate. I still think they're a year away from truly getting over the close-but-no-cigar hump, in actually winning a few games. The Lions are now 11-2.

I don't think there's much argument that the Minnesota Vikings have the best defense in football. The Lions won a nail-biter against them a couple of weeks ago, 19-15. With the game in Minneapolis and the Vikings improving behind center before the trade deadline, I'll give them the slight edge. Vikings win a low-scoring affair, bringing the Lions to 11-3.

While the Miami Dolphins, Tennessee Titans, Arizona Cardinals, and Tampa Bay Buccaneers are better than their records would indicate, the New York Giants are worse than their 5-3-1 record shows. If not for a massive brainfart by Washington Commanders quarterback, Jayden Daniels, the Giants would have been swept by their NFC East foe, and be 5-4. Not only that, the five teams the Giants have defeated have gone 13-34 (.277) so far this season. Even the teams they've fallen to combine to go just 12-15-1 (.429). Especially with the game at home, I have trouble seeing the Lions lose this one. 12-3.

The game at Soldier Field will admittedly be a difficult one to win. Not impossible, of course. If the Lions win the home game of the series, Dan Campbell will be 3-0 against Ben Johnson. Like I did with the Vikings, though, I'll take the home team here, which would drop the Lions to 12-4.

In the final game of the regular season, the Lions go to Lambeau Field to take on the Green Bay Packers. Let's just say, for argument's sake, the Lions lose this one too. That would make them 12-5. 

I think, to Lions fans and haters alike, a 5-3 close to the season is fair. If this happens, Detroit would assuredly make the playoffs, and no matter what detractors say, if you're in, you can win. Detroit's offense is solid, top to bottom. Sam LaPorta may be a top-10 receiving tight end, yet he's been almost invisible in the passing game over the past month - not because he's hurt, but because the Lions offense has so many weapons, sometimes a person will occasionally get lose in the shuffle. Jahmyr Gibbs. Amon-Ra St. Brown. Jameson Williams. Isaac TeSlaa. Sam LaPorta. There's even a chance they could get Isiah Pacheco in December, to back up Gibbs. They're loaded. Even with the worst defense in the league for the first month of the season, the Lions went 2-2, when a lot of teams would have gone 1-3 or 0-4. Since then, their defense has gone from worst to top 10, maybe even top 5. Aidan Hutchinson may be gone, but the Lions season is far from over because of it. For whatever reason, to this point, the Detroit Lions have played better on both sides of the ball, without Aidan Hutchinson starting. Maybe Dan Campbell and company have placed more pressure on themselves to strategize better. Maybe both the offensive and defensive units have taken on added responsibilities and maximized their potentials. I don't know, but this team can't be counted out. The NFC North is far and away the best division in football this year and I would not be at all surprised to see any one of its four teams make it to the Super Bowl, and yes, that includes these Detroit Lions.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Boycotting jukeboxes because of TouchTunes

I love music and enjoy hitting the bar(s) over the weekend, so naturally, when the mood strikes me, I've never been coy about playing some songs on the jukebox. This past Thursday, a friend of mine turned 50, so several friends of her's, including myself, all met up to celebrate the occasion. At around 9:30, a friend of mine and I both chipped in $5 to play some songs on the jukebox. Four hours and 231 skips later, we gave up on hearing the songs we had selected, and went home knowing we had just wasted $5. This wasn't the first time such a thing had happened to me (and many others), and due to that, I'll be boycotting jukeboxes. Why? The scam known as TouchTunes. You see, here's how the plot typically breaks down. A person (or group of people) downloads the TouchTunes app on his/her phone, consumes one too many adult beverages, and due to this, has less care for spending extra money to hear the songs of their choosing right NOW. That's the thing with TouchTun...

A closer look at the Scramble With Friends power-ups

I am unashamed to admit that I'm a nerd. My idea of a good time is playing a word game like Boggle or Scrabble. Thankfully, I (and many others) can play such games via Facebook and/or my (our) cell phone(s). While it seems that cheating has become more commonplace in these games (Words With Friends in particular) than San Diego has had nice weather, I've yet to give in to that craze. One element present with the game Scramble With Friends (Boggle) not present in Words With Friends (Scrabble) are legal boosts called "power-ups," which cost a number of tokens from the 15 available. I've now tried all five power-ups, including the latest one which costs money. So, in case anyone's curious about playing the game or giving these power-ups a gander, here's a rundown of them all: Freeze - I think this is probably my favorite of all the power-ups. With the freeze, time stands still for a matter of seconds, which allows you more time to find words and improve...

Film Critic Steve Rhodes Has Some Issues

Normally, I don't "bash" movie critics, because what's the point? We all have different tastes in film, so who am I to say that their tastes are wrong? But, I just bumped into a critic online the other day, and I really have to wonder about him. There is not much consistency with what he likes and doesn't like. Check that, he dislikes anything with George Clooney, he either strongly likes or dislikes films dealing with politics, and he typically enjoys Arnold Schwarzenegger films. Keep in mind that this is a major film critic. This is not a guy like me who writes blog reviews after I view a film at the theaters. Also keep in mind that I'm very open-minded when it comes to films. I enjoy: comedies, dramas, science-fiction, action, suspense/mystery, horror, romantic comedies, romance, foreign, independent, satires, amongst others. It takes a lot for me to sit down, watch a film, and dislike it. There are only a few films where after the credits start rolling, I...